Discussion about this post

User's avatar
meteor_runner's avatar

I see a few others have pushed back on the running point also. But "Don’t run (it’s bad for your joints)", is not true.

I raced cross country and track throughout high school and college, have logged over 30,000 miles over the past 15 years, etc. So I've got some "joints in the game", and have looked into this extensively. There is no reason to think that even quite large amounts of running have a net negative long-term impact on joints (injuries are possible, but protective and strengthening effects are more common). I think that this myth persists because it is narratively seductive.

Now, what is true is that running has a fairly high incidence of various short-term soft-tissue injuries for people who are starting from a sedentary baseline - plantar fasciitis like you mentioned, shin splints, tendinopathy, etc. In some sense this is a skill issue; you just need to ramp up much slower than it feels like you have to, because the cardiovascular and muscular adaptations for running are faster than various tendon/soft tissue adaptations. If you are already athletic and active, this is less of an issue, but for those of us working modern office jobs and not working out, it very much can be (or other people will be fine).

Now, I also just want to say that running is amazing! My very best experiences in life are kids and family related, but not so far behind are some amazing experiences running. The feelings of power, freedom, fluidity, connection to and mastery of my environment, etc. etc., are really unmatched. I've also achieved my best meditative states/ego dissolution etc. while running, and it's also a great time to think and daydream.

Of course, it can suck when you first start. Absolutely dreadful. And the injury gauntlet to getting started is very real. But the payoffs might be a lot larger than you're expecting. If you do fall in love with running, it will be transformative to your health and may just become your most pleasurable hobby.

Expand full comment
James Sanders's avatar

I've met many people who have fallen in love with running and gotten into great shape. I haven't met anyone who has fallen in love with the elliptical or regarded it as anything but a chore. I'm genuinely unsure how the utils net out when you account for actually enjoying the exercise and the induced additional exercise from this

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts